hexagon logo

Does Translating The Trihedron Ruin "True Zero"?

Hello All!

I'm having a debate with a fellow programmer today on the effects of moving the trihedron away from the CAD's zero point.

This is in reference to a True Position measurement of a hole located at X0 Y14.5.


So there are two different methods to get our alignments and then dimension the true position:

Method 1
"Locate" The Part, by tapping a point on X, Translating the trihedron to that point, tapping a point on Y, Translating the trihedron to that point, etc for Z.

This obviously moves the trihedron around a bunch, and because of that physical features need to be used on the part to "return" the trihedron back to X0, Y0, Z0 on the drawing for the true position measurement to be taken.

Method 2
Leave the trihedron at X0, Y0, Z0 of the CAD model and NEVER translate it. Instead, tap points around the part and align without ever moving the trihedron.


Now, once dimensioned, both of these methods give me the same Nominal Measurement Values, X0, Y14.5.

Both of these methods use the same features to create their Iterative and Best Fit alignments.

Is there any difference in the end?

Please let me know if that wasn't clear enough, and thanks in advance for any help!
Parents
  • I appreciate everyone's input on this. It's a difficult problem to explain but I think I've gotten some valuable responses here.
    As far as I know the only way to tell if my "origin" point is correct is that when I dimension true positions my nominal values should be accurate to the drawing, which they are.


    then you have no issue. let your co-worker program the way he wants, and you go your own way. I have found over the years of programming I have done, there are MANY ways to achieve the end result. I have worked with programmers that create programs I can immediately understand their thought patterns, and one I totally don't get. as they say, "there's a 100 ways to skin a cat", its the results that matter.
Reply
  • I appreciate everyone's input on this. It's a difficult problem to explain but I think I've gotten some valuable responses here.
    As far as I know the only way to tell if my "origin" point is correct is that when I dimension true positions my nominal values should be accurate to the drawing, which they are.


    then you have no issue. let your co-worker program the way he wants, and you go your own way. I have found over the years of programming I have done, there are MANY ways to achieve the end result. I have worked with programmers that create programs I can immediately understand their thought patterns, and one I totally don't get. as they say, "there's a 100 ways to skin a cat", its the results that matter.
Children