Having a question with a program. My part has a profile callout of .040. The report shows +.020 -.020... And my results say .022, and is RED... I'm not seeing how a profile of .040 is out of tolerance when the result is .022?? Something just doesn't seem right....?
Hmmm... its been long discussed that ASME needed to change its profile definition to match ISO. I was unaware of this change in 2019.
Any chance it also stated that all old version of ASME are retroactively updated to the most current standard similar to ISO GPS? If not... The called out version of ASME would take precedence over the current standard. Slippery slop if the demon doesn't take that into account somehow...
slipper57... switch to ISO reporting if that is really what you want...
Hmmm... its been long discussed that ASME needed to change its profile definition to match ISO. I was unaware of this change in 2019.
Any chance it also stated that all old version of ASME are retroactively updated to the most current standard similar to ISO GPS? If not... The called out version of ASME would take precedence over the current standard. Slippery slop if the demon doesn't take that into account somehow...
slipper57... switch to ISO reporting if that is really what you want...
While the GD&T output may lock you into current evaluation practices, legacy reporting and 'T' values allow any analysis output you need to. May not be the best, but it'll be an option where needed.
Even with the new Geometric Tolerance command, you can still report MIN and MAX values in the report window. Then, you'd comply to Y14.5.1-1994 by giving two measured values.
