hexagon logo

Bonus only showing up when good?

2022.2 Is it normal for this version in Geo Tol. that when you have a bonus that when the part is good, it shows the bonus, and when it shows bad it shows no bonus? I'll check back tomorrow for responses.
Parents
  • Do you mean for the size only? If the size is OOT, then there should NOT be any bonus, pretty sure this has been true since MMC was added to GD&T. 10.0+/-0.25, 10.5 gets no bonus as it is OOT


    No bonus at all if the size is OOT kind of defeats the purpose of MMC, in my opinion. Since the MMC is depending on the actual size for functional purposes, it should still give the max bonus even if the hole is oversized at 10.5. I hope this is the case with GeoTol.
Reply
  • Do you mean for the size only? If the size is OOT, then there should NOT be any bonus, pretty sure this has been true since MMC was added to GD&T. 10.0+/-0.25, 10.5 gets no bonus as it is OOT


    No bonus at all if the size is OOT kind of defeats the purpose of MMC, in my opinion. Since the MMC is depending on the actual size for functional purposes, it should still give the max bonus even if the hole is oversized at 10.5. I hope this is the case with GeoTol.
Children
No Data