Zero Position - No Material Modifier - Sortof

Is this a 'legal' callout? We have 4 holes thru the face of a cylindrical part. You know the drill - I can't include the actual print. If need be, I can mock something up.
Datum A = OD, Datum B = Top plane of cylinder, Datum C = 1 of the 4 holes. Should there not be a material modifier here on the position tolerance itself?? Or is the effect the same b/c Datum C is one of the 4 holes?

I'll contact our customer...but they won't likely respond for a month or two...

Parents

CFisher over 1 year ago

Could you draw a quick mock-up? I've had something like this before in one of my company's blueprints

Ive simplified as must as I think I can. This accurately depicts what's on paper. Definitely leaning toward wonky callout in my book...

Attached Files
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Cancel

Reply

CFisher over 1 year ago

Could you draw a quick mock-up? I've had something like this before in one of my company's blueprints

Ive simplified as must as I think I can. This accurately depicts what's on paper. Definitely leaning toward wonky callout in my book...

Attached Files
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Cancel

Children

WilliamL over 1 year ago in reply to CFisher

I'm going to agree with Neil here, and ask the customer if those bolt circles are individual or all 4 as a pattern. This definitely needs clarification. I can't find the print my company had with a similar Position of 0 with a material modifier on the datum sadly to see what engineering said about it.
Cancel
Vote Up 0 Vote Down

Sign in to reply

Cancel