hexagon logo

customer returns piease help

I have a drawing with at least 15 datum structures.my question is this.if datum -e- is the same as datum -d-
as in both being the center of the part is it ok to perform a scan on a profile feature that has a datum callout to datum -d-, to datum -e- alignment.in this case I feel aligning to -e- is more accurate due to the fact it is a circle. datum -d- is outside of part with very little straight surface area to measure.keep in mind I am using a model.I have customer returns and I have moved my alignment several times to see if scan results change the results have all been the same.seems to me if x y z coordinates are correct the scan is accurate.the datums used are center of part -d- or -e- as well as -x- and -y- which is another profile feature on other end of part which I know were specifically machined with the same tool.customer sees .0001 to .015 tolerance variance. tolerance on this profile is +-.0015 Ille take any help I can get.
Parents
  • In the pure sense of it, datum d and e are not the same. They are defined by different features so while their centers may correspond on the drawing, their actual will vary in practice. That's not to say if they are logical or practical, without seeing the part or knowing the manufacturing process, I can't comment on that.

    Also, know that this section of the board is for PC-DMIS NC and NCi which are versions of PC-DMIS designed to interface to machine tools and machine tool probes. Questions like the above are best suited in the PC-DMIS for CMM section of the forum as that gets the most traffic.
Reply
  • In the pure sense of it, datum d and e are not the same. They are defined by different features so while their centers may correspond on the drawing, their actual will vary in practice. That's not to say if they are logical or practical, without seeing the part or knowing the manufacturing process, I can't comment on that.

    Also, know that this section of the board is for PC-DMIS NC and NCi which are versions of PC-DMIS designed to interface to machine tools and machine tool probes. Questions like the above are best suited in the PC-DMIS for CMM section of the forum as that gets the most traffic.
Children
No Data