hexagon logo

Concentricity Changes a lot when I rotate a part 180 degrees.

I have two cylinders on a part that need to be concentric within .002". I noticed that on some parts, not all, the concentricity reports out of tolerance at .0039 for example but then when I rotate the part 180 degrees, the concentricity is suddenly .002 or less.

I align the part by measuring a top plane, leveling to this and setting z origin. Then I measure a circle with 9 hits and make this the x and y origin. Im not locking rotation as I really dont think it matters in this case since its a circular part anyway. I then measure the datum as a 3 level cylinder with 9 hits each level, then measure the next cylinder 9 hits 3 levels.

I don't see how rotating it 180 degrees changes anything especially since I'm taking 9 hits at each level on diameters less than 2.5 inches I should be, in my mind, hitting enough spots to capture anything weird going on with the part. What am I doing wrong here? Thanks.
Parents
  • What probe do you use ? (type of probe, tip and stem diameters)
    What is the value of cylindricity ?
    Do you take the 9 hits in the same way, or do you turn them also of 180° ?
    Is it possible that the probe shanks ?
  • I used a 2x20mm touch trigger probe and a 3x50mm. Cylindricity on the datum .00054" & conc. .0027" and rotated 180 its .00045" & conc. .0014. cylindricity on the other feature .00027 and rotated 180 its .00018 I dont think its shanking out because i think the diameters would be out of spec if it was. I take the 9 hits the same way each time only the part is rotated around the z axis.
Reply
  • I used a 2x20mm touch trigger probe and a 3x50mm. Cylindricity on the datum .00054" & conc. .0027" and rotated 180 its .00045" & conc. .0014. cylindricity on the other feature .00027 and rotated 180 its .00018 I dont think its shanking out because i think the diameters would be out of spec if it was. I take the 9 hits the same way each time only the part is rotated around the z axis.
Children
No Data